BillHamp wrote:
Looks like a sore point for you. I don't want to trigger your suppressed vegan trauma and since this is going exactly nowhere, I'll leave it rest.
Really, that's all you've got?
welch wrote:
James Kim was either stupid or woefully ignorant. He had a place that was shielded from the weather, reasonably insulated and a source of water. Idiot could have lasted weeks in the car, esp. if he allowed snow to build up around it and just kept the roof and an area around one door clear. He clearly had a way to make fire as well. This is what happens when you think knowledge in one area translates to others.
In -40, layers. thermals, good socks, mucklucks for boots, uniform, and then field jacket with the optional liner. For hats, the standard fuzzy hat with earflaps. We usually added neoprene facemasks, and our own gloves, (USAF gloves sucked at allowing you to work with smallish screws AND keep your hands warm) so really, the only areas exposed to the wind would be right around our eyes.
You weren't COMFORTABLE, but you didn't freeze and you had reasonable mobility.
I tend to cut Kim a little more slack. He didn't intend to end up on that logging road, he made a wrong turn and then a series of bad decisions followed. And when I say bad decisions I mean the kind of bad decisions that are so psychologically compelling that it pretty much has to be beaten out of people in survival training. He should have turned around and back-tracked, for instance, but few people do. The tendency is to not want to give up whatever ground you've "gained" and push on through. He could have been more prepared for a survival situation, but he didn't know that's what he was getting into. Couple that with days of freezing at night, lack of adequate food and everything else, he made one monumentally bad decision: To go out looking for help. Now, he did do something that showed some acumen by following a river, but having no idea where he was he didn't realize a cabin was in closer proximity than any settlement he could find following it. Also, he didn't realize that the gully he put himself into was some 20 degrees colder than the surrounding area and, on top of it, he got wet. Once he started that walk, he showed a certain amount of toughness and determination surviving as long as he did. That he was pushed past the limit was demonstrated by his paradoxical undressing. His body just gave up trying to direct heat to his core in the terminal stages of hypothermia.
Rather than criticize him and think he was a fool, I tend to think when it came down to it, he tried up to the point of death.
I carry spare clothes water, MREs, 9 hour candles that can be placed in a Dinty Moore can after I eat it for warmth, accessory rope, knife, folding esbit stove, etc. etc.but I know if the "shit hits the fan" as preppers like to say, I know it's not going to happen the way I expect.
One thing that has always impressed me about military surplus gloves and glove liners, even the supposedly extreme cold weather ones, is just how much they 1. Suck and 2, Seem to be designed to universally fit no one.