Mass deportations in general are extremely illiberal and a much worse evil than terrorism. In a way an instance of mass deportation would be exactly what the terrorists want: by targeting innocents the people who start the deportation would increase support for the most extremist interpretations of Islam, and would give many people a reason to be genuinely pissed at "the West".James Caruthers wrote:Which is why we cannot mass deport people who believe in a nebulous philosophical system which they can interpret in either good or evil ways depending on their own moral character.John Greg wrote:H. Korban said:
But that is of course the fundmental root of both the wonder (for the naive and gullible few) and the ultimate danger (to human social and intellectual freedom) of all religious texts. Understanding fantastical gobbledegook that has no actual, empirical meaning is inevitabley fraught with difficulty; that's not a coding bug, it's a design feature.One must understand, however, that understanding the Quran is not simple. There are bewildering array of interpretations....
All religious texts are quite intentionally vague, opaque, self-contradictory, and so on, and open to any interpretation that any creative individual wishes to endow them with; therefore, any mad man or saint can claim to know specifically and doctrinally what the words mean, and hence what laws they dictate, and hence what the people must do to be saved/holy/WTF, and our mad man/saint can thereby lead a people to whatever ends that mad man or saint should so choose. And it would seem that pretty much invariabley most of the "leading" interpretators, our various beloved mad men and saints, are mostly just out for some variation on power, wealth, and/or social control.
The truth of most religious texts is ultimately the same truth as is carried in a dream: pure interpretation, invention, and fantasy.
In ten years or less there'll be plenty of young Muslims who were evicted from their homes as children, had to suffer poverty and exile at the hands of the "Enlightened Social Engineers" and would no doubt be ready to accept an ideology which would target "Westerners" abroad. So not only is mass deportation incredibly evil, it also can easily backfire into a perpetual war where "Westerners" who visit the countries where the deported were exiled would be seen as easy pickings for revenge.
Good luck getting rid of terrorism in this scenario. Pretty much all "Westerners" would have to abandon Muslim countries to be even remotely safe. And since illegal infiltration and immigration would happen anyway nothing would theoretically prevent some exiled people who would have good knowledge of how the Western law enforcement and security work (because they used to work alongside them or for them before they were exiled) from carrying out more devastating terrorist attacks on "Western" soil.
