Skep tickle wrote:
Uh-oh. Someone better fill her in on the latest decree from Pharyngulite nightshadequeen:
To me, being a [man]/not being a [man] is something someone decides, conciously or not, to be or not to be. ... not defining [man & woman] is the best I can do at defining [man & woman].
(as quoted here:
viewtopic.php?f=31&t=73&p=44497#p44497)
So: which of them is the
truer rad-fem?
No question, it's Taslima.
The real problem with the current mess in atheism is the mixing of sex positive feminism (in which I would include, believe it or not, almost all the FTB/Skepchick crowd) and the anti-pornography feminists like Taslima and Ophelia.
These two forms of feminism are based on different values systems and draw the line on rights in completely different places.
The anti-porn form of feminism has its own unique vocabulary, from which we get many of the phrases that have become commonplace in the skeptical movement in only the last 18 months. These include: mansplaining, privilege, rape culture and various others.
If this sounds a little far-fetched I would ask you to do one thing.
Click on the following link to a feminism 101 page made by radical feminists.
http://radicalhub.com/radfem-101/
You'll instantly recognize many of the phrases and terms that have begun to creep into online skepticism - but coming from people who call themselves sex positive feminists and who disavow the term "radfem".
I personally don't think they (the skepchicks) really believe this stuff. They just use it as a weapon of convenience because it is impossible for anyone to refute (because it is based on a conspiracy theory idea of 'the patriarchy')
I've mentioned in the past that the anti-porn feminists (they never call themselves anti-sex), like Ophelia, absolutely hate the kind of sexual joking that PZ engaged in at Skepticon3.
This incompatibility is a timebomb, ticking under their feet. I think Ophelia is smart enough to keep her mouth shut when her master is exposed as an onstage sex-pest hypocrite, just as she is when virtually all her non-USA use the sort of gendered insults she uses as exhibit 1 evidence against the rest of us. But Taslima is not so encumbent on FTB money or speaking positions.
I would put my money on Taslima being the one who sets off the inevitable explosion.