welch wrote:jesus, I never got the outrage at it. Yes, it's (mostly) unnecessary, (although there's a lot of conflicting evidence I've read on it), and while I am, my son is not, because well, no knives without a reason. But seriously, while I can't judge sensitivity compared to uncircumcised, because, well, I am, I can say that it's not like I sit at home masturbating my insensate wang with a pad sander, weeping at my inability to feel.
I'm not outraged about it, because well, first of all, here it's much of a non-issue, save for the Muslim immigrants who are starting to demand that it be free of charge like other, actual necessary healthcare (which I'm firmly opposed to). Second, because the actual damage it causes seem rather mild in the big picture.
It's just that to me, it's a pretty clear cut case of something that is morally wrong, it invades the bodily autonomy of a person who have no say in the matter, for no real reason whatsoever, other than marking them as a member of a religion (at least here, that's why I'm curious about the reason for american Christians who circumcise their kids).
Cutting of the earlobes of a child serves as a good comparison. Earlobes serves less functionality than the foreskin, and if removed by a professional will leave no unsightly scars. Yet it's, at least to me, pretty clear that parents who have their newborn's earlobes removed is doing something wrong. It's not superbad, it's not child rape or beating them badly, but it's still wrong.
So, again, I'm by no means outraged about it, there are far more important things that are wrong in the world, and people clearly function ok even when circumcised, it's just that it's so obviously wrong to me, probably because we just don't have a history of cutting of body parts of newborns here, so the idea in the first place is so foreign. That, and the underlying hypocrisy where people very likely would freak out if an equivalent medical procedure was done to newborn girls, is why I don't like people who are ok with it.
Also, I just couldn't imagine not having a foreskin, hell, the parts it protects are SENSITIVE, I wouldn't be able to walk properly if someone came and snipped it off!