Kirbmarc wrote:
I've explicitly supported Aneris when she claimed that Chomsky isn't a regressive or even a SJWs, because he isn't (hell the guy advocated for the freedom of speech of Robert Faurisson, a Holocaust denialist). I have my issues with Chomsky in that he's too partisan in his criticism, but he's definitely not in the same boat of PZ Myers or even of Ophelia Benson.
Chomsky is a staggeringly poor example of a classical liberal here. Chomsky argued for Faurisson's "free speech" rights because he was /sympathetic to his views/ and this is obvious from his forward to Faurisson and his (secret) close working relationship with the radical socialist holocaust revisionist imprint La Vielle Taupe that published him. Robert Nozick remembers him gushing over all the holocaust revisionist literature they were sending him at the time and he wanted to give them the French language rights to his most recent book.
Chomsky:
Denies the Cambodian genocide to this day
Minimizes the Japanese genocide to the point of denial and claimed that Japan's invasion of the Asian mainland was "in some respects" (it's always a hedge with Chomsky) greatly beneficial to Asians, for example, saving "millions of lives" in India.
Denies the Maoist genocide during the cultural revolution, denies that hundreds of thousands were executed during North Vietnam's land reforms, denies the genocide of the Miskito Indians by the Sandinistas
Denies the Srebrenica massacre, supported accused Serbian war criminals, defended "Living Marxism" as it denied genocide in Rwanda and Bosnia (again in terms of "free speech" where it was clear he actually endorsed their views.)
On the other hand he had nothing but contempt for the free speech rights of anti-Sandinista newspapers shut down in Nicuragua -- when asked to review them in the 80s, he said his "minimal spanish" was sufficient for him to dismiss them as worthless.
His holocaust revisionism was just one more experiment in his general strategy of sympathising with totalitarian regimes so long as they are the enemies of the Evil US.
So no, Chomsky actually is the archetypal SJW, the kind that defends 9/11 as punching up, if Aneris is a Chomskyista then she admires a contemptible totalitarian hypocrite.