Ericb wrote:Metalogic42 wrote:Jonathan wrote:Amusement to be had at A+ where Hyperdeath the site admin dared to go against the party line by claiming that
"reverse racism" can happen. This has NOT gone down well with the faithful, including two of the mods.
Expect a grovelling retraction soon.
Do they really think that a white kid getting beat up by black kids for walking through the wrong neighborhood gives two shits about an "axis of power"? Oh right, I forgot, they don't care about anyone but themselves and their shitty SJ project.
Identity politics isn't about equality or justice, it's about revenge. The oppressed group has turned the tables on The Patriarchy/Man/Etc. and now creates the categories to plug everyone into. "How do you like that cis-scum? Hmmm, gee this power thing feels pretty good, get the adrenaline flowing. I think I'll keep this up for a while."
Its about collective revenge as well. Even worse.
SubMor straight up admits:
Of course not because privilege isn't about individuals. It's about group averages.
and then ceepolk tops it off with:
if you're on the lower end of the power and privilege axis, you cannot be racist.
Seeing as these two mods are not disagreeing with each other, I think we can say that these two statements can be taken as the Atheism+ consensus. I could be quotemining, but I don't think I am and the original link is up there to check.
Putting these two together paints a very ugly picture: whether or not you get labelled as a racist depends not on what you do, not even on who you are,
but on what ethnic group you are a member of. Yes, other people have pointed this out, but I thought it could do with being made even clearer that this isn't hyperbole, this is what they actually truly believe.
So the morality of a person (assuming racism is worse than what they dismiss as racial bigotry, and it certainly seems so) is judged by the colour of their skin. Maybe this is my privilege talking, but that sounds kind of racist!
Furthermore, note that in this topic they have given up any pretense of fighting for the cause of atheism, secularism, or skepticism. A 5-year-old girl is being denied public education unless she is sent to a school run by a religious group. This is a no-brainer issue for all three of those causes, but all they can think of is "Brown people versus white people! White people are evil!"