acathode wrote:If you take away their politics... and then try to place them on a political scale... you're not going to get anything remotely useful.
Frankly, what you seem to be talking about is the power-hungriness, tribalism, and their totalitarian tendencies. Those are not even remotely exclusive to the right wing, but sadly something you find in all political extremists, no matter if you left, right, up or down. IMO, it's a just nasty part of our human nature, something that have very little to do with left/right politics.
Looking historically, the left is certainly no stranger to tribalism and totalitarianism, but neither are they strangers to valuing your family and community either.
(ps. and no, I'm not even remotely right-wing. I live in Sweden and have traditionally voted left/green. Converted to US politics that makes me a sodding communist or something I suppose?)
I don't think so - in fact, I think thinking of it politically just leads you in weird directions. I don't know why say, abortion, is particularly right wing and environmentalism is left wing. There are probably many good historical reasons but it is tough for me to justify them with a right wing v. left wing ideal. When I think of left wing, it is an ideal of equality v. a comfort with inequality on the right wing. There isn't any right answer to this - obviously making things fair and equal is something many people like, and obviously things are never going to be %100 fair and equal, nor is that an outcome many people would want.
That's why I think of things like tribalism as a right wing value. Valuing your family is a byproduct of evolution and also a right-wing value. To you, your family is more important than a random person on the street. Extending this, your community is more important than some other community. Your country is more important than other country. Etc., etc. To which the leftist might say, you aren't more important than any other person, you're family isn't more important than any other family, and your community is no more important than any other.
Compare this forum, where anyone can come and post and agree and disagree and is more or less on equal footing, to Pharyngula, where you aren't allowed to offend the boss, the regular commenters, or say anything without offering the proper tribute, which always seem to be apologies to everything. It is a tribe. Atheism Plus tends to operate on this level - everything seems based more on hierarchy than equality. I don't think it's close - while lots of people here have right wing politics, this is a leftist place.