#848
by Matt Cavanaugh » Wed Mar 03, 2021 8:00 am
ThreeFlangedJavis wrote: ↑
American propaganda makers depicted Germany in a very different light than Japan. Germany was seen as a great nation gone mad. The Nazis might have been evil but there was still room for the “Good German.” Japan, on the other hand, was depicted entirely as a brutal monolith; Hirohito and the guy on the street were uniformly evil. Such thinking paved the way for the U.S. Air Force firebombing of Tokyo, where over 100,000 civilians died, and for its nuclear bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
The survivors of historical events in Dresden and Hamburg might find the argument a bit incendiary. I suspect that there was more than just racism playing into perceptions of the Japanese. They didn't have much of a reputation for being gracious in victory, did they, and I think the prospect of losing countless men to millions of nutters with sharpened sticks may have had something to do with the nukes. Wish writers of this kind of thing constructed their opinions from all of the facts instead of using just some of the facts to support their opinions.
Who wrote that?
FDR’s pathological hatred of Germans, stemming from a snubbing by some Junckers as a teenager, permeated American propaganda and policy.
FDR, following the July, ’44 Hitler assassination attempt:
The Gestapo and the SS have done us an appreciable service in removing a selection of those who would undoubtedly have posed as ‘good’ Germans after the war… It is to our advantage therefore that the purge should continue, since the killing of Germans by Germans will save us from future embarrassments of many kinds.
On treating Germany post-war:
We have got to be tough with Germany, and I mean the German people, not just the Nazis. You either have to castrate [them] or you have got to treat them in such a manner so they can’t just go on reproducing people who want to continue the way they have in the past.
In the UK, the influential Lord Vasittart consideread the German people,
“a nation of killers.” “Eighty percent of the German race are the political and moral scum of the earth.”
Germany’s first world war cost mankind by and large, directly and indirectly, 25 million lives. And the second, before we are through, will have cost two, three, perhaps even four times as much. Now, a clique can’t do that. The disease is national, and the cure must be national.
Everyone who thinks that the Germans are as other people, only misled, is an enemy of other people…. [W]ho twice tried to strangle humanity? The answer is : all parties in the German nation. Here "is the proof and the story. Its facts show clearly the monster that we shall confront for many years after this war, the prolonged effort and vigilance necessary to tame.
This propaganda never stuck among ordinary Americans or Brits. The sowing-of-salt approach was quickly abandoned, in part because FDR was dead, but also because the propaganda that the Soviets were our slightly more socialist friends quickly wore of.
The hatred of the Japanese as a people in the US was real, and well-earned by the Japanese — though the concept of a ‘nation gone temporarily mad’ certainly applies. Still, THE BEST YEARS OF OUR LIVES contains an interesting exchange between the character who’d fought in the Pacific and his son, who parrots the propaganda about the Japs not valuing life as much as Westerners.
Back in the early eighties, I got into it with historian John Toland at a book reading. He’d asserted that the Japanese people had actually been really nice people the whole time during the war, while it was the Germans who’d been uniformly evil. I asked how this jived with 38 attempts on Hitler’s life vs. 0 on Tojo’s, on the execution of Jews committed in secret by special nazi units vs. the Rape of Nanking committed by regular army troops under orders, etc. His answer: his wife was Japanese, and his in-laws were really nice people.
The USAAF firebombed Japanese cities for the same reason Bomber Command firebombed German medieval city centers: they were highly combustable, and precision bombing had been an abject failure.
[quote=ThreeFlangedJavis post_id=501952 time= user_id=67]
[quote=Lsuoma post_id=501950 time=1614738929 user_id=2]
https://www.google.com/search?q=seuss+racist+cartoons+japanese
Also check out Dr Seuss Goes To War
[/quote]
[quote]American propaganda makers depicted Germany in a very different light than Japan. Germany was seen as a great nation gone mad. The Nazis might have been evil but there was still room for the “Good German.” Japan, on the other hand, was depicted entirely as a brutal monolith; Hirohito and the guy on the street were uniformly evil. Such thinking paved the way for the U.S. Air Force firebombing of Tokyo, where over 100,000 civilians died, and for its nuclear bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. [/quote]
The survivors of historical events in Dresden and Hamburg might find the argument a bit incendiary. I suspect that there was more than just racism playing into perceptions of the Japanese. They didn't have much of a reputation for being gracious in victory, did they, and I think the prospect of losing countless men to millions of nutters with sharpened sticks may have had something to do with the nukes. Wish writers of this kind of thing constructed their opinions from all of the facts instead of using just some of the facts to support their opinions.
[/quote]
Who wrote that?
FDR’s pathological hatred of Germans, stemming from a snubbing by some Junckers as a teenager, permeated American propaganda and policy.
FDR, following the July, ’44 Hitler assassination attempt:
[quote]The Gestapo and the SS have done us an appreciable service in removing a selection of those who would undoubtedly have posed as ‘good’ Germans after the war… It is to our advantage therefore that the purge should continue, since the killing of Germans by Germans will save us from future embarrassments of many kinds.[/quote]
On treating Germany post-war:
[quote]We have got to be tough with Germany, [b]and I mean the German people, not just the Nazis[/b]. You either have to castrate [them] or you have got to treat them in such a manner so they can’t just go on reproducing people who want to continue the way they have in the past.
[/quote]
In the UK, the influential Lord Vasittart consideread the German people, [i]“a nation of killers.” “Eighty percent of the German race are the political and moral scum of the earth.”[/i]
[quote]Germany’s first world war cost mankind by and large, directly and indirectly, 25 million lives. And the second, before we are through, will have cost two, three, perhaps even four times as much. Now, a clique can’t do that. The disease is national, and the cure must be national.
Everyone who thinks that the Germans are as other people, only misled, is an enemy of other people…. [W]ho twice tried to strangle humanity? The answer is :[b] all parties in the German nation[/b]. Here "is the proof and the story. Its facts show clearly the monster that we shall confront for many years after this war, the prolonged effort and vigilance necessary to tame.[/quote]
This propaganda never stuck among ordinary Americans or Brits. The sowing-of-salt approach was quickly abandoned, in part because FDR was dead, but also because the propaganda that the Soviets were our slightly more socialist friends quickly wore of.
The hatred of the Japanese as a people in the US was real, and well-earned by the Japanese — though the concept of a ‘nation gone temporarily mad’ certainly applies. Still, THE BEST YEARS OF OUR LIVES contains an interesting exchange between the character who’d fought in the Pacific and his son, who parrots the propaganda about the Japs not valuing life as much as Westerners.
Back in the early eighties, I got into it with historian John Toland at a book reading. He’d asserted that the Japanese people had actually been really nice people the whole time during the war, while it was the Germans who’d been uniformly evil. I asked how this jived with 38 attempts on Hitler’s life vs. 0 on Tojo’s, on the execution of Jews committed in secret by special nazi units vs. the Rape of Nanking committed by regular army troops under orders, etc. His answer: his wife was Japanese, and his in-laws were really nice people.
The USAAF firebombed Japanese cities for the same reason Bomber Command firebombed German medieval city centers: they were highly combustable, and precision bombing had been an abject failure.